超級星光大道 2010-04-23 終極魔王踢館 第8名決定賽

Description: Episodes:

TIP1: Try both Google Chrome and Firefox
TIP2: How well does your browser support HTML5?
TIP3: Try ctrl+F5 refresh your browser if you see "Video not found".
April 23, 2010
Tipster Rednimer

522 thoughts on “超級星光大道 2010-04-23 終極魔王踢館 第8名決定賽”

  6. [YT] @princess610317
    1 . 做賊的喊抓賊….真是辛苦你了 ( oh my gosh!)
    2.我們”google”見…你知道的….朋友!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^ (別裝熟好嗎？)
    3.死不悔改 ?? (請問你再哪一個幼稚園當算命老師？)
    4.除非文盲看不懂…否則你的話(大家)都看得懂(大家?always你是中華民國代表?)

    Reply ↓

  10. [YT] @princess610317 奧~你看得懂英文嘛?
    我幫你翻譯喔~你看我多貼心阿~你應該交像我這樣的朋友！
    掰掰！再見喔！因為我知道你會回我，差不多一百多次吧

    Reply ↓

  11. [YT] @princess610317
    4 . 你是算命師阿?知道我辭窮，可以幫我算一下嘛，我今年的運勢，有什麼要屢勸我呢？
    5 . 我不是教你不要回我了嗎？幼稚鬼，奧!我不應該用這三個字，因為某人覺得無鞋也有錯！哀呀~你文盲阿 ？
    6 . bye~ see you , cause I know you’ll reply a hundred times again .

    Reply ↓

  12. [YT] @princess610317
    1 . 真的是我先找你麻煩的嘛?可以在CHECK一下，應該不用我教你吧？
    2 . 你的地球面積是只有35,980平方公里?
    3 . 我不知道其他國家怎麼樣，但我們這邊也教正體。

    Reply ↓

  13. [YT] @Jacobdargo 除非文盲看不懂…否則你的話大家都看得懂…請你腦袋清楚一點..我從來沒有理過你…是你莫名其妙回個”你太天真”這樣嘲諷的話我才有所回應….還有!!你若不是台灣人又何必打中文繁體字呢….你已經詞窮了.最好不要再回應…否則再來我就不是這麼文謅謅的”反擊”了!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Reply ↓

  15. [YT] 星光評審真得很不鼓勵創新 之前黃美珍在水一方改編得很有自己的特色 也唱得很好 結果卻被說太前衛 所以標準到底在哪? 黃郁善臉上有許多不甘心 因為她知道自己的表演非常好 以前評審也說就是要把舞台當作表演的場所 所以現在又想要聽小朋友的詮釋方法了? 標準一直變動 難怪無法信服觀眾 其實大家都知道 黃郁善唱得好

    Reply ↓

  16. [YT] 我也覺得黃郁善唱得很好 他有自己的想法 重點是會讓人想聽下去 踢館那位 我聽了十幾秒就快轉…因為詮釋方法都一樣

    Reply ↓

  22. [YT] @Jacobdargo 給予參賽者鼓勵多於批評是看任何比賽應有的正面態度
    當你不尊重別人的評論時就是不尊重你自己
    當你嘲諷否定別人的評論的同時…你已經糟蹋自己的人格與國格而不自知!!!!
    至於”幼稚鬼”這三個字….基本上….只有小學生才會罵
    那麼你現在是不是知道自己有多不成熟了呢???Jacobdargo?????

    Reply ↓

  36. [YT] 我同意節目效果這個說法
    芯不可能那種小東西處理不好
    而且感覺桃子開場時就點名芯了
    感覺桃子好像很維護邊

    以上個人想法
    尊重節目結果

    Reply ↓

  44. [YT] @onlymes
    同意
    沒有參與其中的人真的不能否定他們的用心與感情
    作為觀眾還是把節目當成一種享受或娛樂就好
    沒必要因為互相批評鬧得大家不愉快

    Reply ↓

  45. [YT] It’s really touching to see all the guys share such a strong bond. I think the girls aren’t as easy to make friends with the guys… Huang yushan seems really cold. Su zhiyu is quite young and reserved. Dudu seems to more approachable but it’s weird if she’s really close to the other guys and the other girls are not…

    Reply ↓

  51. [YT] Hu Xia is good. His voice has that element which is soothing to our ears and touching at the same time. He does not put stress to listeners with his vocal and that is a very good ability. Keep up the good work and be consistent.

    Reply ↓

  54. [YT] Huang Yu Shan is surprisingly good this week. Keep up the good work. She is unique and dare to challenge. It makes us wondering what she will do next. Special girl!

    Reply ↓

  56. [YT] Huang Yu Shan performed really well! Uniquely good! The arrangement was spectacularly special unlike other versions of “Somewhere Over The Rainbow” that I’ve heard. Kudos to her. As for Kimberley, I think the song was too tough for her to handle. Norah’s songs arent easy to sing. Her rendition was not jazz enough & rather awkward at certain notes. The judges overrated her b’cos at a young age, she had performed in musical, but that doesn’t mean she can handle pop songs or other genres well too.

    Reply ↓

  57. [YT] Oh no… Huang Wei Jing chose a difficult song. Very tough for him. If he picked a song that he could handle quite well, he might have a chance to move forward. Too bad he didn’t make it through. But he is a hardworking boy so hopefully he can be around in the entertainment scene.

    Reply ↓

  61. [YT] @onlymes 謝謝你…畢竟我們都只是透過螢幕在看節目..無法親身體會真正在比賽者的付出與辛苦…只要能站在星光..無論是參賽者或是PK者都已經很優秀了…對吧…..替所有的人加油吧!!!!!^o^

    Reply ↓

  65. [YT] 真的, 试问批评伟晋的看客们, 你们能做到在比赛里面知道自己是最实力最弱的那一个, 顶着自己被说是靠长相上位的压力, 还是一次又一次去努力去挑战高难度去挑战自己吗? 不是每一个爱唱歌有唱歌梦想的人都会实力满满, 伟晋的努力就很好的代表了这一个群体, 不是一定要实力过人才能有资格为自己的梦想拼搏的. 这一段真的很感动, 掉眼泪了.

    Reply ↓

  70. [YT] @lord0shawn
    今天站在舞台上的不是, 你不能像他们一样为自己的梦想去努力去拼搏, 你有什么资格来说他们哭或者笑就应该去死呢? 积点口德吧.

    Reply ↓

  73. [YT] 小玲和尤其林志炫讲评得很好, 也很对很有说服力. 可是小胖你这一番讲评的主旨是什么?!!! 黄郁善是表演就只能拿4分? 什么叫做小女孩找一首自己喜欢唱的歌不管原唱爱怎么唱就怎么唱就值五分?!!! WTF?!! 你真的拜托快点去shi一shi吧.

    Reply ↓

  74. [YT] 郁善这次唱得让我有惊艳到. 对于不喜欢她的人, 为什么只要是一个外国人或者从国外回来的歌手唱国外的东西大家就膜拜觉得很厉害, 对于本土的人唱国外的东西就是看不顺呢? 她这次真的唱得很不错,除了编曲尤其那个ending是啥东西啊|| 看郁善在唱的时候kimberley都shock到了(yeah she totally should be!) 这个打分真是太瞎了!!! 小胖首当其冲!!!

    Reply ↓

  78. [YT] 姑且不論編曲,光就低音的音質及高音的穩定度而言,今天黃就比Ｋ優出許多.如果超級星光大道是要選未來的歌手,難道只讓她們唱芭樂歌嗎?曲風就必需,只能與原唱一模一樣嗎?還是這些評審太重儒家之道,來者是客,必給高分?

    Reply ↓

  82. [YT] @DANGersome
    Lols. I think you’re getting too fired up. I did not say you were wrong, but rather you seemed a little presumptuous to say “cry doesn’t mean emotional.” I was replying to that comment and took it to mean Yu wasn’t showing real emotion, which I think she was. Now I know you’re implying her SINGING was lacking emotion rather than she was. You’re right, sometimes emoting your feelings is different than emoting a song’s meaning. However your tone still seemed to hold a bias against Yu.

    Reply ↓

  86. [YT] @jibikao 我覺得其實這首歌黃齡是唱得好的，在訪談節目里她就現場唱過很多人的歌，都很好聽。她主要是緊張了，從開頭就覺得她的聲音完全放不開，小女孩還是差點舞臺經驗啊~

    Reply ↓

  87. [YT] 就是爲了黃齡來看這兩期的比賽的，不過確實有點失望，黃齡太緊張了。在很多訪談節目里聽過她清唱，都很好聽，不過今天的表現嘛。。。就像她自己在博客上說的一樣，太緊張了。

    Reply ↓

  88. [YT] 余超颖哭是因为这首歌是冲着台下坐着的那一帮拉芳星光大会的参赛选手唱的 他们一起比赛肯定很有感情 她一个人代表拉芳去星光唱 很有压力 看到台下战友给她打气 就抑制不住情绪 自然流露 我觉得很感人的

    Reply ↓

  98. [YT] @DANGersome Firstly, your simple English is easy to understand, but your ‘compex’ English is Hard to understand, no matter how old the reader is. Secondly, your point of view sounds crazy, no matter who the reader is! Thirdly, SHUT UP! Any normal people with reasonable mind will not argue with u anymore, And I am one of those people!

    Reply ↓

  101. [YT] @363609358 I am writing in simple english to such an extent that a primary school kid can understand. This means that your understanding of english is so “PROFOUND” that you can’t even understand a primary school kid english. By the way, English is no doubt not my 1st language, but I am not bad at it. So, say whatever you want about my english. Also, when was i being rude? You are the one accusing me of being ABUSIVE!

    Reply ↓

  102. [YT] @DANGersome What do u mean on earth???May I suggest u write in ur first language, I mean I can understand Chinese. Nothing personal,OK? If DuDu is as excellent as you say, then see how she goes in the future, our words cannot change anything. Sincerely, it’s none of my business. And youtube network is to provide entertainment and communication,that’s why most of us come here . So plz don’t behave rudely here anymore.

    Reply ↓

  104. [YT] @363609358 Just 2 typo errors and you cant get the meaning? My point of view is that I have my rights to say what i want. And since when was i abusive? Who is being personal right now?

    Reply ↓

  105. [YT] @DANGersome I am sorry I cannot catch your English meaning, but I have to emphasize everyone has their right to show their view which is based on the fact not chicanery ,NOT ABUSING, and I am not here to quarrel with u. JUST STOP IT!

    Reply ↓

  106. [YT] Just a side note. I didn’t think it was fair for 3 shuai to be there from the very beginning. How is it a fair competition if you have 3 people vs 1 person? Whether they’re good or not is a different story. They need to be eliminated along with huang yu shan.

    Reply ↓

  107. [YT] 黃郁善did his best~ but lack of the sweet sound and not natural, that why she deserve the slight lower point. Ms K sing also not that good, but lack of the mature sound. That why she can’t perform good score too… 18 Mark is just a normal mark only~

    Reply ↓

  108. [YT] @363609358 Since when did i do PERSONAL ATTACK? And i will throw my the exact same sentence to you, everyone has their right to like or dislike, i can say whatever I want. And for your info DuDu did not win every time. And are you out of your mind comparing a SINGER and a CONTESTANT? How about comparing Eason of Jacky Cheung with the contestants? See the unfairness if you compare contestants with actual singer? You are the one being personal!

    Reply ↓

  109. [YT] That K girl is totally overrated. She had one good performance and every other time she just plain sucked. Last week she bombed the song but for some reasons they still gave her good scores. I thought that was ridiculous. But this week was too much. Miss Huang obviously had a better performance. This show is totally rigged

    Reply ↓

  110. [YT] @DANGersome It’s the truth DuDu wins every time, then she should be a competitive singer to be compared, do u mean DUDU is not as good as Olivia then she should not be compare with, its extremelly WEIRD! And PLZ dont argue here for an innominate Singer. Everyone has their right to like or dislike do the PERSONAL ATTACK it’s quite RUDE!

    Reply ↓

  120. [YT] @asd123215 就算不能成为一线那又怎样？她是有王菲的那种特点，每次的表演都很新颖很特别，我的眼光从来没差过的。像徐佳莹我一早就看好。

    Reply ↓

  127. [YT] 陶子問小胖的時候表情好好笑

    其實差一兩分真的不代表誰就比較差
    因為評審給分的時候是各自給各自的
    評審自己也不會知道總分會是誰高

    Reply ↓

  157. [YT] @v030201 well, possibly for the very fact that they did not appeal that much to the masses as opposed to him? This show is done partly for the sake of entertainment after all, the producers have to cater to the preferences of the masses.

    Reply ↓

  159. [YT] 哭去死啊。。。怎么男选手都这么阴柔的啊。。。大家还叫边边。。女的名字用叠字就算了，男的也用就有点过了吧？！
    星光都被女人掌控了，剩下几个男的也都走阴柔路线的。

    Reply ↓

  160. [YT] 陶子的『偉晉淘汰論』很好笑，偉晉就是這麼奇妙的躲過許多淘汰…
    雖然他歌藝不是最好，但他有舞台、觀眾緣，態度認真、個性可愛、外型出眾
    他真的很適合進演藝圈…期待他在不同領域出現

    Reply ↓

  161. [YT] DuDu選歌很有guts, 難唱攻擊性也不強，但卻聽到她深情、溫暖的情感…
    前半段聽了真的有進入夢鄉的感覺…（舒服）而副歌把情感拉起…動聽ㄝ

    冠軍候選人…投一票…

    Reply ↓

  163. [YT] 星光是長期比賽的素人選手為主，而魔王有些已經是發片歌手、或是身經百戰的海內外大比賽強手。製作單位是刻意去找魔王們給選手震撼教育（or 刺激收視率）

    Reply ↓

  166. [YT] 即便他不強
    但也請不要糟踏他的真誠與努力
    歌聲再美沒有感情也是枉然
    他的努力已經讓數集後來的評審驚訝不已
    請鼓勵多於批評
    否則…..你也可以去報名試試看
    如果還有星光7的話

    Reply ↓

  169. [YT] @jacklzhj
    其實是製作單位非常刻意找海內外魔王級的pk選手來星6，這是歷屆星光最強pk
    這些pk者幾乎都是經過許多歷練、比賽的 top, 所以會有星6較弱的反差
    若這些pk者去比早期的星光，星1、星2也不一定好過…
    製作單位有點太狠了，或許是收視猛藥吧～

    Reply ↓

  170. [YT] Xin Yii u r the best!! Bian Pin Xian really cant compete u, just he this week got OBVIOUS improve than last week.. so, they see the difference easier.. Xin Yii i always love u.. gambateh.. i know u r sad.. good luck..

    Reply ↓

  171. [YT] 蘇這次有再次突破的感覺…冷冷的搖滾風
    鋪陳也很有漸進感，聲音的穩定度、厚度也夠
    這兩週一次輕快英文、一次搖滾，很有心求進步，表現也不錯喔（18.19分）

    閻羅王已經證明她英文歌（尤其快歌）實力堅強…

    Reply ↓

  172. [YT] @kin313810 一定要合起來的～台語就是這樣。
    不過吳盈靜唱得超好聽，我很久沒有這樣認真想
    聽女生唱台語老歌(經典歌)。大有可為！

    Reply ↓

  174. [YT] 很喜歡Norah Jones的這首歌，但Kimberly真的唱的頗讓人難受….
    低音、尾音都不穩，也沒有韻味…還太年輕了
    我也以為郁善會贏，我想小胖給Kimberly 5分有點超過…

    Reply ↓

  185. [YT] 伟晋是个很单纯可爱的孩子, 又努力不做作, 跟大陆来的选手们也打成一片, 很喜欢你, 希望你加油~~ 也希望在不久的将来能看到你有更多的发展空间!!

    哪位制作人, 赶紧出手啦, 不可多得的偶像剧人才啦!!
    伟晋加油!!

    Reply ↓

  186. [YT] 黃郁善 愈來愈有她自己的想法，而她的想法也開始能和表達呈現的方式做連結了，相較於過去沒什麼變化的風格，似乎她慢慢摸索出了一條屬於自己的道路，這是一個很好的轉變。

    反而是kimberly，選了這首歌反而更曝露出了她聲音上一些不夠細膩的地方。

    Reply ↓

  188. [YT] @FSDD2010 Why are you comparing a contestant and a person who is already an artist. Just because they are on the same stage doesn’t mean you should compare them the same way. You obviously dislike DuDu, that’s why you comment is always negative about her.

    Reply ↓

  189. [YT] @juliaKgrl Also, I did not mention DuDu was more likable or what, but in DuDu’s 30 sec pk, i really hear that she really want to see this person, which is related to the song. She sang with 层次 and 画面. Don’t get me wrong, 余超颖 is a good singer, but i just don’t think she did enough to win the pk. And I don’t really think the show is very unfair.

    Reply ↓

  190. [YT] @juliaKgrl First, its my own opinion how i feel about her. Second, you also don’t know her personally, how can you say that I am wrong or what you think about her is correct. I agree that the she is touched by her fans, but i don’t hear this emotion in her 30 sec pk, all i heard was just that she almost cried but she controlled it. Is that really considered as an emotion to her SINGING? in my opinion, its just visually touching, but vocally, i don’t hear it.

    Reply ↓

  194. [YT] @jibikao
    Contrarily, I think a person’s ability to sing/perform live, unique expressions, and diversification of their talents is much, much, much more important than a person’s “recordability.” Of course, the market may reject such “artists” – but maybe that’s what you meant by your comment?

    Perhaps, my fickleness is part of the problem – can’t seem to retain attention on those who can not expand their talents, uniquely express their viewpoints, and possess enlightened spirits…fast enough.

    Reply ↓

  196. [YT] @DANGersome
    I think she really was touched by her friends and fans’ support. After all, she is human – just b/c she isn’t as “likable” as DuDu doesn’t mean she is faking for sympathy.

    Reply ↓

  198. [YT] 每一屆星光不都是這樣，踢館的永遠都最強，但是當他們也變成星光的人，就會變弱了!感覺真的是噱頭…..，重點是英文歌技巧本來就比較多，真的厲害叫他們唱中文，真的是夠了!!

    Reply ↓

  205. [YT] @SpellTube 每個人都可以表達對音樂的喜好度,你沒辦法接受你所認為反面的意見…就做人身攻擊…..對於你這種人我本也不該浪費時間回應,但到此為止.

    Reply ↓

  208. [YT] @Rocklobsterport That’s a sign of a good “recording artist”. Du Du is no longer a “contestant”. When I watch this show, I watch for “recording artist” and not just typical “good” singers. Good singers are everywhere. 余超颖 is a great singer but she is not a good recording artist yet.

    Reply ↓

  212. [YT] 大家知道历届星光冠军，如一班的林宥嘉，二班的赖铭伟，三班的徐佳莹，四班的方宥心，五班的孙自佑，都有一样的一个特征，就是肉肉的！
    以目前来看，dudu还不需要减肥啦，等拿到六班冠军才减肥啦！哈哈哈

    Reply ↓

  214. [YT] 芯儀的努力,實力,大家是有目共睹的
    這次真的只是評審給邊鼓勵
    才會有這樣的結果
    兩個人的評分標準都不一樣
    千萬不要氣餒
    我支持你!

    Reply ↓

  217. [YT] 偉晉給我們學到的，就是那孩子般純真勇敢的精神，雖然自己實力不足但每每還是挑戰難度極高的歌曲，把握每一次能在舞台上比賽的機會，我認為，就在這個點，他比任何的選手都還來的更有勇氣，他堪稱勇氣大師，鋼盔小王子，不是浪得虛名！！

    Reply ↓

  226. [YT] 張士堂怎會唱成這樣 太可怕了
    林憶蓮的原版 好聽太多了
    他幹嘛一開始掉幾個音
    真的不好聽
    他也不該笑
    又忘詞
    唉

    吳盈靜唱得太感人了

    Reply ↓

  227. [YT] 感覺好像在聽Olivia的演唱會 聲音真的好舒服 很適合配咖啡哈哈
    氣質 每首歌的味道都能唱到心坎裡

    不過其實三帥的趕路也唱的很不錯 和諧 也是很舒服的聲音

    加油 支持Olivia 支持三帥 !!!~~

    Reply ↓

  233. [YT] David老师是看着六班成长的，所以会因为品宪进步了很多， 多给了一分。不过如果抛开其他的， 今天这两首歌听下来，芯儀不应该输得。最多也是平手。（芯儀是非常要强的，现在心里跟定超难受）

    Reply ↓

  261. [YT] 芯儀就敗在頭兩句有點瑕疵，但如果計算整首歌的平均分，還是應該是芯儀勝呢！因為除了頭幾句外，其後是沒可挑剔的！唱得非常非常感人！

    Reply ↓

  266. [YT] 說謊這歌就難在,
    如果唱得太淡然就沒感覺
    反之唱得太灑狗血也就變得芭樂
    張心傑明顯唱得太用力了
    再說,說謊這歌如果練不熟,
    真的很容易落詞

    Reply ↓

  274. [YT] kimberly is a good singer but she shouldn’t try norah jones for now … she needs more time to grow up to get that kind of laid back attitude… agree that if olivia sang the song it would be more suitable..

    Reply ↓

  280. [YT] 黃郁善 should have won, BIG TIME!!!!! David is the worst judge ever! He loves ABC singer….so out of touch….am angry!
    Kimberly picked a wrong song, no emotion.

    Reply ↓

  285. [YT] @frying0stingray 竟然有人會認為郁善會成為一線歌手，我都笑了。連要成為歌手都不可能吧，還一線，不過要當註唱歌手是有幾會啦。時間會證明誰眼光差。

    Reply ↓

  298. [YT] Can’t Kimberly sing some Chinese songs? Sick of listening to it….shouldn’t come if she doesn’t have the gut to try something different, always stay in safe zone! So sick

    Reply ↓

  310. [YT] 這是我聽過邊品憲唱得最好的一次
    第一次聽他唱歌我有感動
    芯儀不知道是不是真的坐太久或狀態不好
    這次有小退步
    一進一退 分數算合理啦

    Reply ↓

  324. [YT] Don’t know why 這首歌在我的認知是一非常 NYC local atmosphere + 坐在0.5樓窗口自談自唱 紓發情緒的歌 Kimberley 唱得油了一點 比較像上流社會的無病呻吟 黃郁善每一次的表演中都會有片段片段非常 unique 的東西 可是這 unique 的東西 每次都落單無法成局 所以總會被批評 其實 郁善很厲害的 就看怎麼琢這快樸玉了

    Reply ↓

  328. [YT] @ChuppahCrunch ok, i don’t understand cantonese, pls explain to me what ‘pk’ means in canto, thank u..anyway, i don’t have malicious intention~.i just feel the name calling of ‘阎罗王’ sounds offending~if i’m her, i’ll feel quite uncomfortable.

    Reply ↓

  331. [YT] 我觉得星光这几届有个共同点 踢馆的都比选手好看。。。真的是选不到好选手 靠请这些高手来增加收视率啊，这几届红的有几位？

    Reply ↓

  334. [YT] 我覺得余超穎有一點趕拍~不是說沒有在節奏上，但是如果比較拉拉唱的版本和余超穎的比起來，拉拉比較從容，有掌握整首歌的感覺。余超穎如果心裡的讀秒慢一點點，就會比現在更好~~

    Reply ↓

  343. [YT] 邊品憲有很明顯的鼻腔共鳴，很好聽
    不過林芯儀的歌唱技巧更勝一籌
    那個死小胖把她講得麼好為什麼沒給5分？
    星光評審的水準真的是收視每下愈況的主因

    Reply ↓

  347. [YT] i rlly like 黃偉晉, he improved SO much and is so hard working, such a likable person, i rlly hope he gets the chance to enter the entertainment industry maybe act in some idol dramas and sing in the future 🙂

    Reply ↓

  349. [YT] 吳盈靜今天唱的很好~真的很有畫面感~看到一個為愛傷心的女孩哭著在阿嬤懷裡聽阿嬤說以前的故事和自己青春時候的愛情。很感動~~
    今天堂堂唱的也還不錯~可惜唱錯詞了。不過他也唱出了原唱者要表達的感情。
    我覺得不分軒輊~

    Reply ↓

  360. [YT] 我觉得郁善才是市场的需要，有亮点、有特点、有外形条件，音乐走向对的话将会成为一线歌手，谁还会迷恋只有包装没有实力的歌手，这就是华语市场的通病，永远不是歌声走先，第一届的Yoga不见得是纯偶像，他有辨识度及特色。

    Reply ↓

  363. [YT] @pisce16 我也覺得是，朋友告訴我說這屆星光很好看，我就連看了兩周，不過只是節目做的更好看了，這屆選手水平真的是還好，都9強了，居然還有三帥這種連pitch都不准的選手沒被淘汰，而且完全沒有一個代表人物

    Reply ↓

  365. [YT] 对呀！我觉得郁善很好啊！如果在美国偶像里这就是他们所追求的出彩&原创！！真不懂那些老师怎样评！！有够烂！！Kimberly的声音也太不受控了吧！黄大炜及死胖子到底会不会评啊！？郁善竟然会输，真的不公平！！！

    Reply ↓

  368. [YT] why did he have special coverage after the show lasting like five minutes?
    what about all the people who got eliminated before?
    They didn’t get any extra time except give the speech when knowing that the got eliminated.
    I just don’t see why people like him so much.

    Reply ↓

  386. [YT] I don’t know why I did’nt come 应该翻译成:我不知道为什么没有达到高潮。
    At 15, I don’t think she understand the feeling of this song.
    She came across sounding contrived.

    Don’t Know Why
    I waited ’til I saw the sun
    I don’t know why I didn’t come
    I left you by the house of fun
    I don’t know why I didn’t come
    I don’t know why I didn’t come

    Reply ↓

  389. [YT] 黃郁善抖音太多了啦!!!!好不舒服啦!!!應該被淘汰的是黃郁善吧……… 超吊lo! alot of people don’t her for long long long time, Why she still here!!! kick her fuck out !!!!!!!! hate her!!!!!!!!!

    Reply ↓

  392. [YT] 不可否認黃郁善的聲音跟唱法都很有特色
    不過星光一開始就說明了評分標準是以會不會紅為主
    君不見目前從選秀出來的 比較紅一點的都是星光而非超偶?
    黃郁善的風格恐怕不是大眾市場會接受的

    Reply ↓

  398. [YT] 其实今天苏芷妤有表现得很好啦, 只是她刚好就对上同一歌路而且又那么强的对手, 她就吃亏点啦, 如果今天她对上的是唱抒情歌曲的, 她就有胜算啦!! 加油!!

    Reply ↓

  402. [YT] Wow how did Xiao Pang give Kimberly’s performance 5 points? It was so obvious that she chose a wrong song. She lacked the depth and soul for it; that Norah Jones song is supposed to be jazzy and easy on the ears. Kimberly’s rendition just made me cringe.

    Huang on the other hand surprised me. They should at least have gotten the same points. She wasn’t worse than Kimberly!

    Reply ↓

  408. [YT] Those who criticise 林志炫 are just being childish. He’s a great judge who delivers very constructive comments since the past seasons.

    黃齡 didn’t do very well today. Face it! She even got breathless towards the end, it was pretty obvious.

    Personally I think the PK-ers are more stressed than the contestants, ’cause everyone expects them to be crazily good. But even the good ones get nervous and have their not-so-good days.

    Reply ↓

  410. [YT] i dn’t really like 黃郁善 but i think she did a rlly rlly good job this time, and the way she changed it was awesome too, how did she lost when kimberly sang so “monotone”-like during the entire song…i like kimberly better to be honest, but i think 黃郁善 should’ve won this time

    Reply ↓

  417. [YT] 這根本就是打歌嘛!
    越來越商業化!

    個人認為,胡夏早該贏的,個人合理的懷疑:是不是製作單位故意搞個平手然後再讓人有打歌的機會,手法太粗糙了…

    Reply ↓

  428. [YT] I agree. music and performance is a form of art. there is people like it and there is always people against it. Even a vegas show is entertaining enough for audience like me. So, what is important? Isn’t it putting up a good perfomance is equally important? can’t understand the judges thou…..

    Reply ↓

  429. [YT] Why does he have to leave? I think huang yu shan should’ve left a long time ago! this sucks =( He’s the same age as me, seriously sad to see him go =/

    Reply ↓

  433. [YT] @superman2011 人家林小胖也是媒体在炒作消费他啦，没有必要侮辱人家。我想说的是每个人都有追求梦想的权利，但是不一定唱歌有技巧就一定要当歌手，听歌主要听的还是诚恳和情感。太过炫技会让人觉得有压迫感。

    Reply ↓

  442. [YT] 不提谁在放水，我觉得胡夏唱的更有感情而且声音没有压迫感，非常舒服。小胖虽然是制作人，但是不能说你本人对歌曲的诠释就一定适合所有的歌手和所有的听众。

    Reply ↓

  448. [YT] 不知道為什麼總覺得星光的評審都不喜歡林芯儀
    每次我覺得他唱的很好時分數都不高
    這次就算沒比邊高至少也要同分吧
    我覺得林芯儀的位置唱的很好聽阿至少讓我很傷感

    Reply ↓

  449. [YT] I have to say Season 6 has turned out to be very exciting! I love how they start with 4 teachers choosing the students. That part was so exciting. And now this PK round is just as exciting! Good job, the producer!

    Reply ↓

  452. [YT] It’s about time 黄伟晋 leaves the show. Peach has helped him pass so many rounds but 黄伟晋 is really not that good. I think he should at least go for acting. He has the look.

    Reply ↓

  454. [YT] Wow…. Du Du did really well!! I think Du Du should have won. Of all the singers in today’s show, Du Du and Olivia handle the “minor parts” the best. Du Du doesn’t have the range but Du Du’s singing is very “delicate” just like Olivia.

    Reply ↓

  456. [YT] This girl from China actually sings very well. This type of song fits her better but she made some mistakes… she still looks too nervous.. and that very last note.. ugh.

    Reply ↓

  464. [YT] Oh my god!!! This is why Peach is the best host. She is so smart to even make jokes on the “song titles”. “PS, I love you” and then “Don’t love me!”. LOL That part is so funny. Peach is the best!!

    Reply ↓

  466. [YT] Wow, this part is pretty touching. Go Brian! He actually has the best skill among the students. He just needs to let it go… be wild on stage. He needs to worry more about touching people’s heart rather than singing that highest note or the perfect pitch. Go Brian!

    Reply ↓

  470. [YT] @firenoodle Yeah, the first two lines.. she wasn’t ready but after that, I thought Lin is the most emotional of all. The preview made me think that she did really bad but I thought she did quite well after the first two lines.

    Reply ↓

  480. [YT] 沒聽過原唱 黃郁善改編的版本剛開始覺得不錯 但是後面感覺有點改的太離譜了 聽到後面真的果然不愧為覺得跳tone女王 跳的太遠了 林志炫真的說的沒錯 唱好了半首歌

    Reply ↓

  482. [YT] @chia0302 Oh oh.. I have a feeling the show wants to kick out 黃郁善. I thought she did pretty well. Yeah, I know it’s too fancy but I thought she presented herself really well, better than Kim.

    Reply ↓

  485. [YT] Damn, Kimberley still won’t choose a Chinese song? Oh come on, this is like the 4th time on the show? I think she can try to sing a Chinese song! She is too young to sing song well. She seems to be worse and worse. The first two times are great but after that, the 16-year girl sounds better.

    Reply ↓

  486. [YT] @0XDoYouLoveMeX0 Actually, I think 林志炫 is brave enough to criticize or at least give some negative comments. Just because the PKers are great, it doesn’t mean they are perfect. Whether you agree with 林志炫 or not is different story. I am a bit disappointed in 黃齡’s performance. I don’t think this song fits her.

    Reply ↓

  492. [YT] come on guys.. kimberley’s not that bad..
    she’s young and needs more training..
    but her voice is really good for her age..
    seriously.. stop criticizing her.
    she’s good..

    Reply ↓

  518. [YT] kimberley好像沒剛出來時的自信笑容,不知道發生了什麼事,k小姐的高音部份真的不錯,但低音真的要練一下,感情就不能作準始終經歷有限

    Reply ↓

  519. [YT] @QueenJCLN 蘇芷妤唱得很好聽 可是聲音沒有18歲的感覺
    我非常喜歡kimberly的唱法 因為妳還聽的出那種小女孩的誠懇 那種很純的聲音 請妳不要對15歲的小女孩留這種言 有這種勇氣上台去比賽就已經很強了 而且他完全沒有覺得自己是大魔王的感覺 只是陶子覺得的

    Reply ↓

  522. [YT] 谁來告訴我K小姐是憑哪一點稱得上”魔王級”? 聽他唱歌好不舒服喔…..每次都唱大歌卻一點感情都沒有…pitch不太好又抖來抖去的…蘇芷妤頂多大他個兩歲，唱得好太多了!

    Reply ↓

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Variety