華人星光大道 2011-11-13 強敵來襲 生死拼搏踢館賽 Round 1

Description: Episodes:

TIP1: Try both Google Chrome and Firefox
TIP2: How well does your browser support HTML5?
TIP3: Try ctrl+F5 refresh your browser if you see "Video not found".
November 13, 2011
Tipster Rednimer

220 thoughts on “華人星光大道 2011-11-13 強敵來襲 生死拼搏踢館賽 Round 1”

  6. 我覺得唱惠妮休士頓或是任何一個英文歌的歌聲是要一個有渾厚或是聲音必須有厚度唱起來才會好聽!所以我覺得踢館那位唱起來會讓人頭暈….聲音單薄~
    雖然關施敏16分但是總體表現一直很好，不太能夠因為單次失誤而判出局~

    Reply ↓

  7. 不知所謂的評審，16分不用走，是因她是關詩敏的原故嗎？那麼不用比下去吧，直接把冠軍交給她就好了

    Reply ↓

  10. the 13 year old girl, although she sings VERY well, BUT the down side is.. if she ever wantta become a real singer / performer.  She really gotta OPEN her EYES at least for a minute while she sings. It looks too weird that through the whole song, she sings with eyes closed at all times.

    Reply ↓

  15. 請評審解釋一下為何在比賽節目裡，21分會輸給的16分的，正因為就算再好的選手，也會一時的失誤而被淘汰，這正是歌唱比賽好看的地方，很多厲害的歌手不
    也是如此而飲憾，所以突顯穩定性很重要，一失足及成千古恨。然而華人星光大道，竟然在全球華人觀眾朋友之前，有此乖張之舉，有此違乎常理之行徑，必然其中
    有任憑自由心證之評審，那麼要自由心證，何必評分。本人看了很多個比賽節目，從沒有一個節目是這麼不公正和隨便的，希望不要成為別人的笑柄，試想一個公開
    的比賽節目，分數高的輸給分數低的，誰敢來比賽？本人對此兩位歌者，並無偏愛，只覺得她們選錯比賽場地，不能得到合理的對待而悲哀！

    Reply ↓

    • 都說了是要選一個能發片得歌手。長篇大論的﹐你煩不煩啊。如果真的淘汰了關詩敏﹐就真的是”乖張之舉﹐違乎常理之行徑了”。

      Reply ↓

      • 如果關詩敏是那麼好，馬前失足也可以發片，只要唱片制作人說可以就好了，不能犧牲別人和破壞全球的規矩！

        Reply ↓

        • 嘿﹗只有你這種白痴才不知道這世上已不知有多少人被犧牲了﹐還說規矩哩。想來你不過是一個乳臭未干的小孩子﹐不懂事卻在這扮大人﹐說出這種幼稚話來。

          Reply ↓

  16. 請評審解釋一下為何在比賽節目裡，21分會輸給的16分的，正因為就算再好的選手，也會一時的失誤而被淘汰，這正是歌唱比賽好看的地方，很多厲害的歌手不
    也是如此而飲憾，所以突顯穩定性很重要，一失足及成千古恨。然而華人星光大道，竟然在全球華人觀眾朋友之前，有此乖張之舉，有此違乎常理之行徑，必然其中
    有任憑自由心證之評審，那麼要自由心證，何必評分。本人看了很多個比賽節目，從沒有一個節目是這麼不公正和隨便的，希望不要成為別人的笑柄，試想一個公開
    的比賽節目，分數高的輸給分數低的，誰敢來比賽？本人對此兩位歌者，並無偏愛，只覺得她們選錯比賽場地，不能得到合理的對待而悲哀！

    Reply ↓

  17. 請評審解釋一下為何在比賽節目裡，21分會輸給的16分的，正因為就算再好的選手，也會一時的失誤而被淘汰，這正是歌唱比賽好看的地方，很多厲害的歌手不
    也是如此而飲憾，所以突顯穩定性很重要，一失足及成千古恨。然而華人星光大道，竟然在全球華人觀眾朋友之前，有此乖張之舉，有此違乎常理之行徑，必然其中
    有任憑自由心證之評審，那麼要自由心證，何必評分。本人看了很多個比賽節目，從沒有一個節目是這麼不公正和隨便的，希望不要成為別人的笑柄，試想一個公開
    的比賽節目，分數高的輸給分數低的，誰敢來比賽？本人對此兩位歌者，並無偏愛，只覺得她們選錯比賽場地，不能得到合理的對待而悲哀！

    Reply ↓

  18. 請評審解釋一下為何在比賽節目裡，21分會輸給的16分的，正因為就算再好的選手，也會一時的失誤而被淘汰，這正是歌唱比賽好看的地方，很多厲害的歌手不
    也是如此而飲憾，所以突顯穩定性很重要，一失足及成千古恨。然而華人星光大道，竟然在全球華人觀眾朋友之前，有此乖張之舉，有此違乎常理之行徑，必然其中
    有任憑自由心證之評審，那麼要自由心證，何必評分。本人看了很多個比賽節目，從沒有一個節目是這麼不公正和隨便的，希望不要成為別人的笑柄，試想一個公開
    的比賽節目，分數高的輸給分數低的，誰敢來比賽？本人對此兩位歌者，並無偏愛，只覺得她們選錯比賽場地，不能得到合理的對待而悲哀！

    Reply ↓

  19. 請評審解釋一下為何在比賽節目裡，21分會輸給的16分的，正因為就算再好的選手，也會一時的失誤而被淘汰，這正是歌唱比賽好看的地方，很多厲害的歌手不
    也是如此而飲憾，所以突顯穩定性很重要，一失足及成千古恨。然而華人星光大道，竟然在全球華人觀眾朋友之前，有此乖張之舉，有此違乎常理之行徑，必然其中
    有任憑自由心證之評審，那麼要自由心證，何必評分。本人看了很多個比賽節目，從沒有一個節目是這麼不公正和隨便的，希望不要成為別人的笑柄，試想一個公開
    的比賽節目，分數高的輸給分數低的，誰敢來比賽？本人對此兩位歌者，並無偏愛，只覺得她們選錯比賽場地，不能得到合理的對待而悲哀！

    Reply ↓

  20. 請評審解釋一下為何在比賽節目裡，21分會輸給的16分的，正因為就算再好的選手，也會一時的失誤而被淘汰，這正是歌唱比賽好看的地方，很多厲害的歌手不
    也是如此而飲憾，所以突顯穩定性很重要，一失足及成千古恨。然而華人星光大道，竟然在全球華人觀眾朋友之前，有此乖張之舉，有此違乎常理之行徑，必然其中
    有任憑自由心證之評審，那麼要自由心證，何必評分。本人看了很多個比賽節目，從沒有一個節目是這麼不公正和隨便的，希望不要成為別人的笑柄，試想一個公開
    的比賽節目，分數高的輸給分數低的，誰敢來比賽？本人對此兩位歌者，並無偏愛，只覺得她們選錯比賽場地，不能得到合理的對待而悲哀！

    Reply ↓

  21. 請評審解釋一下為何在比賽節目裡，21分會輸給的16分的，正因為就算再好的選手，也會一時的失誤而被淘汰，這正是歌唱比賽好看的地方，很多厲害的歌手不
    也是如此而飲憾，所以突顯穩定性很重要，一失足及成千古恨。然而華人星光大道，竟然在全球華人觀眾朋友之前，有此乖張之舉，有此違乎常理之行徑，必然其中
    有任憑自由心證之評審，那麼要自由心證，何必評分。本人看了很多個比賽節目，從沒有一個節目是這麼不公正和隨便的，希望不要成為別人的笑柄，試想一個公開
    的比賽節目，分數高的輸給分數低的，誰敢來比賽？本人對此兩位歌者，並無偏愛，只覺得她們選錯比賽場地，不能得到合理的對待而悲哀！

    Reply ↓

  22. 請評審解釋一下為何在比賽節目裡，21分會輸給的16分的，正因為就算再好的選手，也會一時的失誤而被淘汰，這正是歌唱比賽好看的地方，很多厲害的歌手不也是如此而飲憾，所以突顯穩定性很重要，一失足及成千古恨。然而華人星光大道，竟然在全球華人觀眾朋友之前，有此乖張之舉，有此違乎常理之行徑，必然其中有任憑自由心證之評審，那麼要自由心證，何必評分。本人看了很多個比賽節目，從沒有一個節目是這麼不公正和隨便的，希望不要成為別人的笑柄，試想一個公開的比賽節目，分數高的輸給分數低的，誰敢來比賽？本人對此兩位歌者，並無偏愛，只覺得她們選錯比賽場地，不能得到合理的對待而悲哀！

    Reply ↓

  26. I don’t understand why there are so many haters of Sharon Kwan. Because she has many fans? You know that opposite effect? More fans = more haters? Because objectively thinking, she is indeed the best contestant in the competition. And probably the only one that has the best looks and greatest potential of debuting as a celebrity. In fact I don’t think her performance deserved such a low score of 16. It’s certainly not as good as her previous performances and the chosen song certainly has a part to play, not exactly a song you’ll fall in love with the moment you hear it in the first place, but 16?? The judges are certainly using a more stringent set of rules and with greater expectations as compared to the other contestants when they are awarding her scores, precisely because she’s been so good. I agree with the rest who are saying “How can you eliminate one of your best (if not rather clearly the best) contestant?”

    Reply ↓

    • Honestly, to be fair, yes, Sharon is better than the girl who got elminated (in general). However, this is a singing competition, and every time you step onto the stage could very well be your last. If you screw up, be it in your singing or your song choice, that should be it. She was crap, 16 was a fair score, and they should have sent her packing. To call her one of the best? I think you’re another viewer that’s been charmed by SK, cause it has been a headscratching two months seeing all the high scores and rave reviews that the judges have been giving her. But hey, it happens every season, there’s always one contestant that the judges always seem to rave about.

      Reply ↓

  27. Life is unfair, that’s why 16 OUTSCORED 21.

    Actually, why is score even being granted if the lowest score is not being eliminated? Should just let the judges vote on who they wanna eliminate.

    Reply ↓

  31. Ask yourself, what do you feel if you get 21 and you’re eliminated over 16 marks? Sharon has stable performance all this while, yes that’s right, and yes she shouldn’t be eliminated solely on this performance, but i don’t think it’s fair enough!! 

    Reply ↓

  34. haha …bunch retards complaining about the judges.

    They NEVER said they eliminate the lowest score.

    Most of the time 小胖 would say the elimination base on contestant’s previous performances, their potential.

    So learn the f ing rules before you retards yell out judges are unfair or biased.

    Of course they are not gonna eliminate one of the best, if not the best contestant over one bad performance.

    關詩敏 is in a different league than 王琳蓓, if you think 關詩敏 should have been eliminated then u are just dumb, really really dumb!  

    I’m not a fan of her, but at least i know how good she is.  Just stop hating and talking like idiots.

    Reply ↓

    • 如果跟原唱一樣厲害 還需要在這邊比賽嗎?

      愛看又愛罵  來這邊比賽就是要磨

      要再進步 不懂就不要看 —

      Reply ↓

  41. 李玉钦
    她曾在1999年《Astro 新秀大赛》中打败大马著名歌手曹格拿下冠军，及获得同年度的《全球华人新秀歌唱大赛》银奖

    Reply ↓

  50. UNFAIR UNFAIR UNFAIR UNFAIR UNFAIR UNFAIR UNFAIR UNFAIR UNFAIR UNFAIR………………..
    BIAS BIAS BIAS BIAS BIAS BIAS BIAS BIAS BIAS BIAS BIAS BIAS BIAS BIAS BIAS………………..

    Reply ↓

    • 他們從來沒說過是淘汰最低分  從以前到現在都不是….
      評審很多次淘汰前都說淘汰是看以往的表現和未來可朔性加上這一場表現

      Reply ↓

        • Although I am malaysian, I still think that the judges made a fair decision, I don’t think wang ling bei sang well this time. From an audience aspect, she needs more improvement to be made.

          Reply ↓

  68. seems like they plan to bring her to the final but will not crown her the winner b/c of backlash…watching these shows something the producer watches the hype of each contestant somtimes winner are staged by the production not the contestants

    Reply ↓

  72. 淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃淫娃 where r u?

    Reply ↓

      • 怎麼可能， 看清楚一些。 明明抽籤時已經打扮好了， 怎麼休息時卻完全沒有打扮？
        抽籤后，上場前， 休息 就要卸妝換衣？ 再上場時又把衣服，妝換回來？

        只能說 如果不是賽前定的， 就是黃捷剛巧提起海嘯而已

        Reply ↓

        • 他们其实每次都知道对手唱什么歌，因为节目还没开始他们都会到现场练习还有对key。只是有时候也要假装不知道。这样子节目看起来才比较精彩。

          Reply ↓

          • 嗯。。即使踢館的有到現場練習對key， 也不一定知道 誰對誰吧？只是知道那些人將會唱什麽歌。。
             除非一早就已經訂好， 而不是在錄影現場抽籤決定。

          • 你根本就沒有去想到樂隊。你當這些樂手都是神不需要練習嗎？因為正式比賽時不能重來，所以樂手還有阿咪需要時間來編曲跟彩排。先抽完籤確定好是哪兩首歌後再進行最後的彩排。這些樂手老師們的壓力不亞於選手。你坐在電視前面就只會懷疑，累不累啊？

          • 只是討論， 也不是一直在懷疑他們吧。 我實在不知道是怎麼進行的， 也只能用我自己所理解的來推理出節目的進行。
            我也知道樂隊老師們是需要練習的， 但我以為他們他們或許練好了每一首歌， 那到時候什麽歌什麽次序上都可以 （那如果你知道真的不是這樣的話， 我當然接受）。 當然如果有誰知道實際上錄影時是怎樣的流程和製作，我一定不囉嗦。

            而且， 節目怎麼播， 我就怎麼看，和理解。 在懷疑是不是有內定還是什麽的並不是我啊。  

  76. sharon kwan should go instead of ling bei. judges are being bias. now i am starting to believe the rumor saying sharon kwan is the “pre-determined” champion. F**K those judges!

    Reply ↓

    • they probably didn’t base it on just this week’s performance alone, if we can consider their scoring to be unbiased. if that’s the case, wang ling bei has had lower scores overall than guan shi min

      if you consider their scoring to be biased then there’s nothing to argue about because then there are no commonalities between your and their scoring systems… and it would be like comparing apples and oranges

      Reply ↓

    • well, although it is a shame to see things like that happen, it might be partially true. Even if she doesnt win the competition, she will at least be in the finals, because the producer of the show will “escort” her to the finals to retain their TV ratings, because Kwan is by far the most popular contestant in the show. Doubt the producers will sabotage themselves by handing Kwan an early exit. Sad, but probably true.

      Reply ↓

    • I can understand why you felt that way but there is no need to be rude.  Judging from the scores, Kwan’s is indeed lower; however, it does not necessarily mean her score would have been lower than Crystal’s (ling bei) if they sang against each other. The competition is at the stage of the top 10 and I believe that determining the ranking among these 10 candidates should take more than just one performance into consideration.  Even ling bei herself admitted that she made a lot of mistakes along the way at hte end, isn’t it?  It is already an achievement for anyone to be among the top 10.  We should give all of them and judges credits for that. Just my two cents.

      Reply ↓

    • 要不是胖子忘詞還有雙雙墊底翎蓓早在兩個禮拜前就該被淘汰了。如果翎被跟關詩敏一樣唱過好幾次接近滿分的分數，今天他就不會被淘汰。偏心的人不是評審，而是你。

      Reply ↓

    • She is just overrated. Very overrated. She can sing, her voice is not bad, but its a very normal voice and her singing ONLY have techniques so far, no real emotions for most of the songs, dun think she even understand the lyrics at all… Maybe its coz she is young? Anyway, she have no more potential already.

      Reply ↓

          • Although I am Malaysian, it is obvious that kwan is better than wang. This is the fact. I think it’s because the judges jump into the conclusion too early of saying that kwan should be the ultimate winner so it actually raise a bit of concern amongst audience. The fault does not lie at kwan as a contestant, it should be the judges because they are suppose to judge each singing accordingly, not giving some sort of ridiculous verdict.

    • huh?  are u serious….

      if u think 琳蓓 is better than 關詩穎…then u must really don’t know how to tell people’s singing level….

      Reply ↓

  78. this is so unfair! sharon kwan should go instead of ling bei! the judges are being bias. now, i am starting to believe the rumor saying sharon kwan is the “pre-determined” champion! FUCK YOU JUDGES!

    Reply ↓

  79. 其實如果你很厲害. 來踢館就可以了. 可以一戰成名. 反而四個月一直比下去會有點讓人厭倦,你再厲害我也覺得還好.

    Reply ↓

  82. 關詩敏唱王菲的歌，聲音特色力道吸引力等等等等，完全被比下去了。。。這個(選唱粵語歌的)新嘗試真的是選錯時間點吖。。。還是格格厲害，國語粵語英語都唱得那麼好聽，

    Reply ↓

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Variety